Skip to main content

Should I eat back the calories burned from exercise?

Written by Carbon Diet Coach

Our answer is no. We know many popular apps recommend this, but we don't, for a few reasons.

Reason 1

All monitors (including watches) that claim to track "calories burned" during exercise significantly overestimate them. A recent study found that, on average, these devices overestimated calories burned during exercise by 28–93%. If you burned 500 calories, your device might tell you that you burned anywhere from 630 to nearly 1,000. That's why many people think they're eating in a calorie deficit but can't lose weight.

Reason 2

It can lead to an unhealthy cycle of eating more and then exercising to "burn it off." It's very difficult to out-exercise a poor diet.

How Carbon accounts for your exercise

Carbon factors in the exercise you're doing by adjusting your macros to reach your desired rate of progress each week. As long as you're hitting your macro targets and checking in regularly, the app will adjust to find where you need to eat to progress.

Tracked-calorie review

Carbon also reviews your progress based on the calories you track. If you eat beyond your targets and still make progress toward your goal, Carbon will raise your calories at check-in to match your average weekly intake.

We built this in response to feedback from endurance athletes, and it has proven successful at supporting endurance training. So you don't need to log workouts to account for the extra fuel your training requires. Just log what you eat, check in each week, and the app will adjust to where you need to be.

Did this answer your question?